A deeply disappointing afternoon at Firs Park as Shire made their home debut in 2007. There was almost nothing to cheer in this display and the visitors had the points wrapped up less than halfway through the match without having to play well or do much.
Just about the only positives Gordon Wylde can take were hte five star display of keeper Anton Nugent, who stopped the Spiders going home to Glasgow with a bigger win, and the return to the heart of the defence of Stephen Oates, who played his own part in keeping the score respectable.
There was a surprise before kick-off as Wylde announced his team minus full-backs Steven Learmonth and Paul McAloney. Instead, he opted for a 3-5-2 formation with Oates, skipper Andrew Brand and Carl Thywissen as the back three. Paul Brownlie made a rare start up front with te re-called Steven Dymock while Paul Tweedie was a surprise inclusion in the five man midfield.
A fairly flat opening period gave the advantage to neither side but, after 12 minutes, Thywissen was short with a pass on the half-way line and Queens' David Weatherston pucked up the ball , outsprinted Brand and cut into the penalty box before beating Ngent with a low angled drive that crept into the net at the far post. A fine solo effort and the visitors were 1-0 up.
After 21 minutes it should have been 2-0 as Robert Dunn picked up the loose ball on the six yard line but his effort was brilliantly blocked by Nugent's legs.The Shire keeper was a busy man as the half wore on. He had to dive low to smother Paul Paton's free-kick and dived full stretch to push a Mark Ferry effort wide for a coerner kick.
But on 36 minutes not even Nugent could stop Shire falling two goals behind. The home defence were caught sleeping at a throw in, which Paul Ronald collected before racing down the byline and cutting back for the unmarked Stuart Ketrtlewell to stroke home.
Nugent's one man quest to stop Queen's Park running up a rugby score carried on after the interval. After 49 minutes Ferry was clean through but the keeper denied him with a brave block wirth his legs. That said, Paton should have scored with the rebound but blasted the ball over. Two minutes later the visitors squandered another chance when Ronald sent a free header wide from Mick Dunlop's cross.
Soon after the 3-5-2 experiment was abandoned with the introduction of McAloney for Joe Boyle. He went to right-back, Derek Ure switched to left-back, Thywissen and Oates filled the central defensive roles, with Brand moving into a four man midfield. Brownlie was withdrawn from the forward line to play wide on the left with Tweedie partnering Dymock in attack.
The transformation was immediate. With a couple of miuntes Shire created their first real chance of the game and Dymock ought to have scored with a diving header from a pinpoint McAloney cross. But at the other end Nugent was covering himself in glory. His one handed tip over the bar from Weatherston was the save of the match, but even better was his miraculous double block from Ferry when it seemed certain the Queens man would score.
It was small conso;lation but Shire finished the game on top. Inside the final five minutes David Crawford had to make a good save from Paul Stewart's long range effort and, in injury time, Marc McKenzie burst into the box and fired goalwards only to be denied by a decent smothering save.
Shire : Nugent, Boyle(McAloney 52), Oates, Brand, Thywissen, Tweedie, McKenzie, Stewart, Dymock(Adam 73), Brownlie(McBride 64), Ure.
Queen's Park : Crawford, Paton, Dunlop, Canning, Agostini, Cairney(Quinn 71), Kettlewell, Dunn(Carroll 71), Ronald(Bowers 80), Weatherston, Ferry.
Referee : Steven O'Reilly
Attendance : 292