The club's dreadful record in cup competitions continued with this first round Scottish Cup exit at Ochilview, but that doesn't even begin to tell the full story of a game which was a roller coaster ride of varying emotions for Shire.
Two goals down after just ten minutes, the faithful were looking at another hammering. Then indiscipline reduced Stenhousemuir to nine men after Paul McGrillen and Greig Denham were sent-off. With the two man advantage Shire levelled things to 2-2, but then threw away the chance of causing a huge upset as carelessly as a bit of rubbish in the street.
By full-time the Shire fans in the crowd of 405 were left shaking their heads in disbelief after watching their team invent a new way to lose when defeat seemed impossible. But when the evening had begun many of those same fans were wondering whether the Warriors would better Arbroath's tally of seven against a once-again non-existent Shire defence.
It took the home team just six minutes to score, although Jim Mercer's strike was a fortuitous one, taking a massive deflection on its way into the net. But there was no fluke as Tommy Sinclair made it 2-0 in ten minutes, heading home Joe McAlpine's cross. It could have been more, but Mercer headed wide when it seemed easier to score and Colin Cramb had a good effort saved by Derek Jackson.
Then on 22 minutes an off-the-ball incident left Shire's Stephen Oates on the ground and, after consulting with his linesman, referee Steven Duff produced a red card for Paul McGrilen. The sending-off took the wind from the Warrior's sails and Shire managed to gain a small fothold in the game.
On 39 minutes they were awarded a free-kick well outside the area but the defensive wall could not stop Adam Owen reducing the leeway with a powerful shot. That made it 2-1 and Shire's chances improved almost on the stroke of half-time when Denham was first booked for a foul on Iain Diack, then sent-off for arguing about it.
With a two man advantage for the whole of the second half and just a single goal behind, Shire suddenly became favourites for an unlikely win. Within a minute of the re-start Ally Graham flashed a shot wide of the post and for a while Shire were camped in the Warriors penalty box.
Graham went off in 56 minutes to be replaced by Steven Dymock. The young striker's first intervention was to volley a cross into the net to make it 2-2. With half an hour to go and the scores level surely Shire would make the two man advantage tell and go on to win ? The truth is they never troubled Warriors keeper Willie McCulloch again.
And they left worrying gaps in defence. It was hardly a surprise when they caught Shire napping at a throw-in, pushed the ball down the line for McAlpine who crossed for the unmarked Cramb to volley Stenhousemuir back in front. Shire were never likely to recover, and didn't.