Shire were left sitting at the bottom of the Third Division table after an uninspiring performance in the game that mattered more than any other so far this season. The team gifted Elgin City two goals while scarcely creating a chance worthy of the name. It was a huge let-down for everyone conected with the club.
Manager, Dennis Newall, promised changes after the previous week's defeat at Queen's Park and was true to his word. Johnny Walker made his return to the midfield, whilr Steven Dymock made his first start in the league since joining in the summer. Carl Thywissen and Steven Blair made way. Aaron Gillespie deputised for the unavailable Derek Jackson in goal.
And the home side could have the ideal start in just twlve minutes. Johnny Walker played the ball into Ally Graham, who, with his back to goal, laid it off to Iain Diack. Shire's top scorer hit a rasping shot which Kieron Renton in the Elgin goal saved brilliantly. But from there it was all downhiil.
There was an ominous moment in 17 minutes when Gillespie over committed himself, allowing Elgin Chris Gardiner to round him. Thankfully, the Elgin man managed to miss the empty net.
Elgin didn't pose too much of a threat after that, although they were presented with the opening goal on a plate after 42 minutes. Marin Johnston broke clear and was brought down by Gillespie. The Shire keeper was booked and Mark Booth gave Elgin the lead from the penalty spot.
The visitors' half-time substitute, Gary Wood, threatened to run riot after coming on. Within five minutes of the re-start he had missed two empty goals. Later on, he was unlucky to see his shot comev back off the post. Shire's own half-time sub, Andy Brand, came closest for the home team with a 20 yarder which had Renton scrambling.
Shire gambled on getting an equaliser late on. But Ally Graham couldn't get his header from Johnny Walker's cross on target, although he did come close. Then Iain Diack was unlucky to see his shot on the turn drift just over the bar. Five minutes from the end Elgin went 2-0 up. Mark Tyrrell was caught in possession, allowing Johnston to race clear and score with a low shot under Gillespie's body.
Shire : Gillespie, MacKay(Thywissen 81), Livingstone, Oates, M. Tyrrell, Walker, Dymock, P. Tyrrell(Brand 46), Diack, Graham, Ure.
Elgin City : Renton, Cumming, Dempsie, J. McKenzie, Kaczan, Scullion(Easton 87), Bremner(Wood 46), Booth, Johnston, Gardiner(Melrose 70), Muir.
Referee : Willie Collum.
Attendance : 201.